In a recent interview with Jessica Stroup, she was asked how her character compared to the characters from the original show. Her reply was quite interesting:
What character from the old show does she correspond to?
Luke Perry [Dylan]. He was a rebel and independent, but he also was tied into the group as a whole and was a huge vital part. I like the idea that, 20 years later, it’s the girl who’s the Luke Perry type. The strong, cool, do-what-she-wants-to-do type girl. It’s girl power.
Well, kind of. Dylan was certainly a rebel and independent. He surfed and had a vintage car and didn’t care about college or typical markers of success and had a raging alcohol and drug problem. And oh yeah, all of that was to cover up his broken heart from having to make his own way in the world and not having any real adult guidance or support and so lashing out against the world. I wouldn’t call him that powerful. And I’m not sure it really would say that much for feminism and “girl power” were Silver’s character really his equivalent.
However, I don’t think Silver is much like Dylan at all. She hasn’t really shown anything out of the ordinary – she has problems with her mom, sure, but her most intense rebellion is that she has a blog! And we all know bloggers are totally intense independent rebels. (I sure am.) Until she stirs up some serious shit – taking Dixon to Mexico, throwing flowerpots at Brenda in the street, skipping her SATs – I don’t find her very Dylan-like at all.